What would stop you from trying ShowMySites (https://www.showmysites.com/leaderboard/) this month? Be specific about how you handle this today. Also say the maximum you would pay per month in USD (0 if nothing).

Page reviewed

ShowMySites - Top Website Creators Leaderboard

https://www.showmysites.com/leaderboard/ (opens in a new tab)
Saved screenshot of ShowMySites - Top Website Creators Leaderboard
Screenshot saved with this question. The live page may have changed.Open full image ↗

10 fictional AI personas. Exploratory perspectives, not a survey of real customers. Methodology & limitations

Simulated interest

20/100

AI synthesis, not measured demand

Suggested price range

$0–20

Median $10 · simulated willingness to pay

Response sentiment

Positive 0%Neutral 40%Negative 60%
The takeaway

What this panel suggests

The main reason someone would not try ShowMySites this month is that the product is perceived as a poor fit for how they already run directories. Respondents described existing workflows built around Google Forms, Typeform, Notion, Airtable, and Google Sheets, where they manually review submissions, update counts, and maintain rankings. In that context, a public creator leaderboard feels adjacent to the job they need done rather than central to it; one response captured this mismatch directly: "I don't see how a leaderboard fits into that." The strongest conditional interest appears where ShowMySites can replace manual checking or reduce repetitive tracking work: "I'd need to see if this platform can streamline that process significantly." That makes integration and automation the key trial trigger, not generic directory discovery. Pricing sentiment is cautious: the maximum stated willingness to pay ranges from $0 up to $20/month, with a median around $10, suggesting value must be immediately practical and time-saving. This is a synthesis of synthetic responses, so it should be treated as a hypothesis for follow-up research, not measured demand.

A hypothesis to test

Pricing & positioning

Test whether the product can reduce manual submission tracking enough to justify a paid trial; the main barrier is fit, not outright refusal to pay.

Observed willingness to pay is low but not zero. The lower end is $0, with a small cluster willing to pay around $10-$20/month if the product meaningfully streamlines submission handling and ranking.

Recurring themes

Workflow misalignment with current directory operations
“I don't see how a leaderboard fits into that.”Read Thore Hentschel’s response →
Manual submission tracking is already the default
“I currently process submissions manually from Typeform into Notion and Sheets, which is time-consuming but I have a process that works.”Read Beverly Kihn’s response →
Need clearer integration and automation before trial
“I'd need to see if this platform can streamline that process significantly.”Read Menka Varma’s response →
Public leaderboard positioning feels less relevant than internal management

Objections to investigate

  • Lack of clear integration with existing workflows (Airtable, Sheets, Notion)
  • Product focus on public leaderboards vs. internal directory management needs
  • Unclear pricing structure and value proposition relative to current free/low-cost methods
  • Perception that the tool adds manual work rather than reducing it

Use these findings to plan customer interviews or experiments. How to interpret AI research

What the panel said

Click a name to open that persona’s full profile.

Dean Rice-Keelingnegative

This ShowMySites leaderboard feature doesn't quite align with my current needs. My focus is on curating and reviewing no-code and AI tools for my directory, which I manage meticulously in Airtable and Google Sheets. I'm not looking to showcase my own project submissions or climb a leaderboard based on website count. The core of my operation is the quality and categorization of tool data, not personal ranking. If this were to offer a service for tracking directory submission volume or analyzing creator engagement within my specific niche, I might reconsider. As it stands, the value proposition doesn't fit my workflow. Therefore, I wouldn't pay for this service. $0 per month.

Simulated interest: 10/100

Beverly Kihnnegative

This month? What would stop me is the lack of clear benefit for my specific directory project. I currently process submissions manually from Typeform into Notion and Sheets, which is time-consuming but I have a process that works. I'd need to see how ShowMySites integrates with my existing workflow or offers a tangible time-saving that outweighs the manual effort I'm already doing. The pricing isn't clearly defined for what I need, it seems to be based on number of websites submitted, which isn't directly applicable to my directory management. I'm not willing to pay for a leaderboard feature when my focus is on managing submissions.

Simulated interest: 20/100

Thore Hentschelnegative

ShowMySites appears to be a leaderboard for website creators, which is interesting, but it doesn't directly address my current workflow. I manage inbound submissions for our B2B software directory using Airtable and publish them via Webflow, enhanced by a custom automation stack. My primary concern is refining this existing process for efficiency and accuracy. I don't see how a leaderboard fits into that. If it offered advanced analytics on submission sources or categorization trends, I might reconsider. As it stands, I would not pay for this service.

Simulated interest: 0/100

Menka Varmaneutral

What would stop me from trying ShowMySites this month? Honestly, the biggest barrier is understanding how it actually integrates with my current workflow. Today, I manually check every website submission we receive via Google Forms and WhatsApp, then log it into a spreadsheet. I'd need to see if this platform can streamline that process significantly. I'm not seeing pricing information readily available on the page, which makes it hard to estimate. If it offered a clear benefit for automating our vetting and leaderboard updates, I might consider paying around $20 per month, but without more clarity on features and cost, it's difficult to say.

Simulated interest: 40/100

Norman Rogahnneutral

This looks interesting, but my main concern is the manual nature of tracking competitor activity and updating my directory. I currently do this by spending about an hour each day manually checking a competitor's submission leaderboard and then updating my shared Google Sheet. While this leaderboard is neat, I'd need to understand if it automates any of that data aggregation for me. If it doesn't, it's just another source to manually check, which is precisely what I'm trying to optimize. If it *does* streamline that process, I'd consider paying around $20 per month.

Simulated interest: 40/100

Aline Aubrynegative

Today, I meticulously manage our client-facing directory of creative agencies. Incoming website submissions are processed through a paid form tool, and then I update our internal Coda board, cross-referencing portfolios with our specific criteria to adjust weekly rankings. This involves significant manual data entry and reconciliation, which occasionally leads to typos and rework. The primary obstacle to trying ShowMySites this month is understanding how it integrates with our existing workflow and if it can truly automate the verification and ranking process without requiring additional staff or complex setup. I need to be convinced it reduces manual workload and improves data integrity. Regarding cost, without more clarity on features and how it benefits our specific operation, I cannot assign a value. I would need to see a clear ROI and how it addresses my current problems, particularly scaling verification. For now, I would not pay.

Simulated interest: 10/100

Deeptendu Mahajanneutral

My current directory operation is very manual, so I'm always looking for ways to streamline things. The biggest thing stopping me from trying ShowMySites is understanding how it would fit into my existing workflow. Today, I use a Google Form for submissions and manually update a Google Sheet with counts and rankings. I'd need to see if ShowMySites can automate or at least simplify the data entry and ranking process for my directory of remote-work tools without requiring a huge time investment upfront to learn it. If it could help me manage submissions and see rankings without all the manual checking, I might consider it. I would pay at most $10 per month.

Simulated interest: 30/100

Lucas van Loonnegative

This ShowMySites leaderboard looks interesting, but it doesn't quite fit my current needs. My work involves meticulously curating a design resources directory, which means I'm constantly processing and categorizing new website submissions. Today, I handle this by manually logging everything into Excel and Trello, assigning review statuses by hand before updating our monthly leaderboards. I'd need a tool that integrates with my existing workflow for managing and qualifying submissions, not just displaying a public leaderboard. If it could automate the initial tagging and categorization based on our criteria, I might consider it, but without that, it's just another data point. Given my budget constraints and preference for open-source, I'm hesitant to add another subscription. The maximum I would pay is $0 per month.

Simulated interest: 10/100

Ida Lakinneutral

This tool looks interesting for showcasing creators, but honestly, right now, my main hurdle is budget. We're a lean startup, and while we pay for Airtable Pro and Typeform, expanding our software subscriptions is tough. I handle creator tracking by manually reviewing submissions in Typeform and then updating our Airtable base to see who's submitting most often. It's time-consuming, but it's what we can afford. I'd need to see a clear, immediate ROI or significant time-saving benefit to justify another monthly cost.

Simulated interest: 30/100

Ermilo Rocconegative

This 'ShowMySites' platform, particularly the leaderboard feature, doesn't seem directly relevant to my current needs. I manage a curated directory of Italian freelancers, which requires a manual vetting process to ensure quality. While I appreciate the idea of showcasing projects, my focus is on lead generation for my clients and maintaining the integrity of my niche list. The current system handles submissions via email and I review them manually. I'm exploring tools to automate this process for my directory, but this platform appears to be for showcasing individual creators' websites rather than managing a directory of service providers. Without a clear integration path or a direct benefit to my lead generation goals, I wouldn't consider paying for it. Perhaps if it offered a way to submit and manage profiles for my directory, that would be different. But as it stands, I don't see the value for my specific workflow.

Simulated interest: 10/100

Keep exploring.

Find your next question or see which topics divide AI panels.

Keep exploring

What would you ask next?

Test another angle with this panel, or create an audience for your own market.