If a free web tool helped you pick ETFs for your PEA or brokerage account, which feature would make you come back every month: (a) overlap detection between your ETFs, (b) fee/TER comparison, (c) PEA eligibility checks, or (d) tracking your monthly contributions? Which one, and why?

Page reviewed

ScanETF — Rayon X : analysez, optimisez et suivez vos ETF

https://scanetf.com/ (opens in a new tab)
Saved screenshot of ScanETF — Rayon X : analysez, optimisez et suivez vos ETF
Screenshot saved with this question. The live page may have changed.Open full image ↗

10 fictional AI personas. Exploratory perspectives, not a survey of real customers. Methodology & limitations

Simulated interest

75/100

AI synthesis, not measured demand

Suggested price range

—

No numeric price estimates in the answers. Ask a pricing follow-up to collect them.

Response sentiment

Positive 100%Neutral 0%Negative 0%
The takeaway

What this panel suggests

Across the synthetic responses, overlap detection is the dominant reason people would return to ScanETF every month. Eight out of ten respondents picked it as the feature that would create a recurring habit, mainly because it solves a real pain: hidden duplication, overlapping exposure, and the need to manually compare holdings across ETFs. Several respondents framed their current workflow as tedious spreadsheet work, so a tool that instantly shows where ETFs duplicate each other feels like a true time-saver and risk reducer. By contrast, fee/TER comparison was seen as useful but not especially sticky; one respondent said fees can usually be found on fund pages, which makes this feature feel less unique as a monthly reason to come back. PEA eligibility was acknowledged as important for French investors, but more as a situational check than a recurring use case. Tracking monthly contributions was mentioned as helpful, but it was not the feature that most clearly created a habit loop. Overall, the answers point to overlap detection as the strongest retention driver, with the others acting as supporting utilities rather than the core monthly reason to return.

Recurring themes

Overlap detection is the clearest monthly retention hook
“For me to consistently use a tool like ScanETF each month, the most critical feature would be the overlap detection between my ETFs.”Read Alfredo Pfeffer-Zemlak’s response →
Users want to replace manual spreadsheet cross-checking
“My current process involves meticulous cross-referencing of allocations and ISINs in Excel, and I'm always concerned about unintentional duplicate holdings.”Read Triloki Nath Chattopadhyay’s response →
Fees, PEA checks, and contribution tracking are useful but less sticky
“Fee comparison (b) is important too, but I can usually find that on the fund pages.”Read Muriel Franey’s response →

Objections to investigate

  • Fee data alone is not differentiated enough to bring users back monthly
  • Monthly contribution tracking feels more like bookkeeping than a decision tool
  • PEA eligibility is valuable, but mainly as a one-time or occasional check

Use these findings to plan customer interviews or experiments. How to interpret AI research

What the panel said

Click a name to open that persona’s full profile.

Alfredo Pfeffer-Zemlakpositive

For me to consistently use a tool like ScanETF each month, the most critical feature would be the overlap detection between my ETFs. Given my meticulous approach to portfolio analysis, understanding precisely where I might have unintended concentrations is paramount. While fee comparisons and contribution tracking are useful, seeing the actual overlap helps me refine my asset allocation and avoid unnecessary risk. PEA eligibility is less relevant for my UK-based accounts, so that would be a secondary concern.

Simulated interest: 75/100

Muriel Franeypositive

If a free web tool could help me with my ETFs, I'd definitely come back for the **overlap detection** (a). I'm always trying to streamline my holdings, and seeing where my ETFs duplicate exposure is exactly the kind of efficiency I look for. Fee comparison (b) is important too, but I can usually find that on the fund pages. PEA eligibility (c) isn't relevant for my U.S. accounts, and tracking contributions (d) is something I do manually in my spreadsheets anyway. The overlap detection feels like the most valuable insight that would save me time and effort.

Simulated interest: 70/100

Triloki Nath Chattopadhyaypositive

Overlap detection between ETFs is the most crucial feature for me. My current process involves meticulous cross-referencing of allocations and ISINs in Excel, and I'm always concerned about unintentional duplicate holdings. While fee comparisons are important, and PEA eligibility is relevant for French investors (not me), detecting overlaps directly addresses a significant pain point in my existing manual workflow and ensures better diversification. Tracking monthly contributions is a standard function that many tools offer, but identifying hidden overlaps is a more complex analytical challenge that would save me considerable time.

Simulated interest: 75/100

Elly Schwalmpositive

For me, the most crucial feature would be (a) overlap detection between my ETFs. I spend a considerable amount of time exporting data and comparing spreadsheets, as I want to ensure my portfolio is truly diversified and not just a collection of similar investments. Understanding the overlap helps me refine my index exposure, which is a core part of my personal investing routine. While fee comparison and PEA eligibility are important, I already have a system for checking those. Tracking monthly contributions is useful, but less critical than preventing unintended concentration risk.

Simulated interest: 85/100

Didier Leclercpositive

For me, the most compelling feature would be the overlap detection between my ETFs. Given that I meticulously track my portfolio and aim to optimize it, identifying duplicate holdings is a significant pain point. While PEA eligibility checks and tracking monthly contributions are useful, detecting overlaps directly addresses the complexity of consolidating my holdings and avoiding unintended concentrations. Fee comparison is also important, but I can already derive that from the TER data I collect.

Simulated interest: 75/100

Deborah Dietrichpositive

Well, if a free tool could help me pick ETFs, I suppose the most useful feature to keep me coming back each month would be tracking my monthly contributions. It ties directly into how I manage my budget – seeing that consistent saving add up is quite satisfying. Overlap detection is interesting, and checking PEA eligibility is good, but honestly, the monthly contribution tracking feels most aligned with my personal approach. I do a lot of manual tracking in Google Sheets now, so seeing that automated would be a real time-saver, you know?

Simulated interest: 75/100

Jeremiah Mannpositive

From a data perspective, overlap detection between ETFs would be the most compelling feature to keep me coming back monthly. My core approach to investing involves minimizing redundancy and ensuring my diversification is intentional, not accidental. While fee comparison is always important, and PEA eligibility is relevant for some investors, I'm primarily concerned with the underlying holdings and how they interact. Tracking monthly contributions is useful, but less critical than understanding the portfolio's actual composition and avoiding unintended concentration. Identifying overlap directly addresses a key problem I'm always trying to solve: optimizing the inputs for efficiency and risk management.

Simulated interest: 70/100

Juna Molpositive

If a free tool could automate some of my current monthly tasks, the most compelling feature would be (a) overlap detection between my ETFs. My biggest concern is ensuring I'm not inadvertently doubling down on certain sectors or companies, which is precisely what I spend hours trying to reconcile manually. Seeing the overlap clearly identified would save me significant time and provide the transparency I need to feel in control of my family's investments. While fee comparisons are useful, and PEA eligibility is relevant for French investors, the overlap is the pain point I'm actively trying to solve.

Simulated interest: 75/100

Sofia Ragonepositive

The most compelling feature for me would be the PEA eligibility checks. As an investor in Italy, understanding any specific tax advantages or restrictions for my ETFs is paramount, and this "PEA" appears to be a French-specific tax wrapper. If this tool can reliably identify which of my ETFs are eligible for such advantages, it would be invaluable for optimizing my portfolio's tax efficiency. Overlap detection is also important, but PEA eligibility directly addresses a potential blind spot given my focus on cross-border investments and regulatory nuances.

Simulated interest: 75/100

Jeff Volkmanpositive

Well, the most compelling feature for me would be the "overlap detection between your ETFs." I spend a good chunk of time each quarter ensuring my portfolio is efficient, and identifying any redundant holdings is a key part of that. While fee comparisons and tracking contributions are useful, overlap is something I actively look for and can be a real drag on performance and diversification if not managed. PEA eligibility is less relevant for my US-based accounts.

Simulated interest: 70/100

Keep exploring.

Find your next question or see which topics divide AI panels.

Keep exploring

What would you ask next?

Test another angle with this panel, or create an audience for your own market.