What do you use today instead of Pencil2D (https://www.pencil2d.org/) (a competitor, a spreadsheet, doing it by hand)? Compared with that, what would make Pencil2D better or worse for you, and what would keep you on your current option? Also say the maximum you would pay per month in USD (0 if nothing).

Page reviewed

Pencil2D Animation | Open Source animation software

https://www.pencil2d.org/ (opens in a new tab)
Saved screenshot of Pencil2D Animation | Open Source animation software
Screenshot saved with this question. The live page may have changed.Open full image ↗

10 fictional AI personas. Exploratory perspectives, not a survey of real customers. Methodology & limitations

Simulated interest

24/100

AI synthesis, not measured demand

Suggested price range

$0–0

Median $0 · simulated willingness to pay

Response sentiment

Positive 0%Neutral 100%Negative 0%
The takeaway

What this panel suggests

These respondents mostly use other drawing and animation tools today, including professional suites and open-source alternatives such as Photoshop, Illustrator, Krita, OpenToonz, Synfig, and Inkscape, and some still rely on manual hand-drawn or spreadsheet-based workflows. Compared with those options, Pencil2D is most appealing when it is seen as a lightweight way to combine raster and vector work in one place. That aligns with the page’s claims about minimal design, raster/vector support, and being free and open source. The biggest reasons to stay with current tools are that they already work well enough, switching may add learning effort, and some respondents worry about workflow fit, stability, or missing advanced capabilities. In other words, Pencil2D looks like a potential simplifier, but not yet a clear upgrade over established tools. The maximum stated monthly willingness to pay was 0, which suggests very strong price sensitivity in this sample and a strong expectation that the product remain free or at least not require a subscription.

A hypothesis to test

Pricing & positioning

Do not assume direct subscription willingness from this batch; the clearest signal is zero stated monthly spend and strong attachment to free/open-source options. Treat monetization as a hypothesis to test, not a validated demand signal.

If pricing is tested, position it around optional support, services, or premium add-ons rather than a mandatory subscription. The main value proposition here is fitting into existing raster/vector workflows without extra friction.

Recurring themes

Open Source & Free Value
“Since it's open-source and free, I wouldn't pay anything per month.”Read Lindsey Romaguera’s response →
Raster/Vector Integration
“Pencil2D sounds interesting because it combines raster and vector, which is exactly what I do.”Read Lindsey Romaguera’s response →
Sufficiency of Current Tools
Workflow Integration & Stability

Objections to investigate

  • Sufficiency of Current Tools
  • Learning Curve & Complexity
  • Lack of Advanced Features
  • Workflow Integration & Stability

Use these findings to plan customer interviews or experiments. How to interpret AI research

What the panel said

Click a name to open that persona’s full profile.

Lindsey Romagueraneutral

Right now, I'm juggling bitmap sketching and vector line work, mostly in Photoshop and Procreate for roughs, then cleaning up in Illustrator. For notes and revisions, it's spreadsheets, which is fine but clunky. Pencil2D sounds interesting because it combines raster and vector, which is exactly what I do. If it was genuinely more intuitive than my current setup, especially for hand-drawn elements, that would be a big plus. However, my main concern is workflow integration; I’d need it to play nicely with my existing tools. Since it's open-source and free, I wouldn't pay anything per month.

Simulated interest: 40/100

Simon Weimerneutral

I use a mix of free drawing software and hand-drawn storyboards for my class shorts. Pencil2D is open source and free, which aligns with my current workflow. The ability to switch between raster and vector sounds interesting, but my current tools, though basic, are sufficient for my needs. What would make Pencil2D better for me is if it offered more advanced features for complex character animation or integration with other free pipeline tools. What would make it worse is if it had a steep learning curve or if its stability was an issue, as I rely on robust software for deadlines. Given that Pencil2D is completely free and open source, I would not pay for it. My current setup works, and investing money in software isn't feasible with my stipend.

Simulated interest: 0/100

Leo Bartolettineutral

Right now, we use OpenToonz for some of our cutscenes and character loops. For other things, it's mostly manual work or whatever small scripts I can whip up to speed things along. We also track our tasks in a spreadsheet, which is... basic. Pencil2D sounds interesting with its focus on being easy to use, and the ability to switch between raster and vector is a nice touch. The fact that it's open-source and free is a huge plus, especially given our studio's limited budget. Honestly, if it could integrate smoothly with our existing OpenToonz workflow or offer a significant time-saving advantage for specific tasks we struggle with, it might be worth considering. But for now, since it's free, I'd probably just try it out myself to see if it fits our needs before even thinking about paying.

Simulated interest: 30/100

Alexis Schaeferneutral

Currently, I'm sketching out early concepts by hand for our pitch decks and explainer videos. I then digitise those using our existing Adobe suite. Pencil2D being open-source and free is appealing, especially since we already mix free software with manual work. However, I'm cautious about adding another tool if it requires significant cleanup or doesn't integrate smoothly. The minimal design sounds good, but I'd need to see if the raster/vector switching is truly seamless and if it actually saves me time rather than adding more manual steps. Since it's free, I wouldn't pay for it.

Ameyatma Khatrineutral

Currently, my students and I are using a mix of free, open-source tools that can run on our older school laptops. We've found some lightweight options, but they often lack the features or stability we need. The biggest advantage of Pencil2D is that it's open-source and free, which is crucial for us. If it runs smoothly on our machines and offers better drawing or animation controls than what we have, that would be a significant improvement. However, if it requires more powerful hardware or is difficult to learn, we'd likely stick with our current setup. Given its open-source nature, I wouldn't pay for it.

Simulated interest: 10/100

Peggy Pacochaneutral

Right now, I'm hand-drawing frames on my tablet and exporting them as MP4s, after storyboarding in spreadsheets. It's very manual and time-consuming, but it works. Pencil2D sounds interesting, especially the raster and vector options and its open-source nature. Being free would be a huge plus, given our nonprofit budget. However, I'm concerned about how it integrates with my current workflow—specifically, if it can handle exporting simple MP4s efficiently for social media and if it simplifies or complicates the frame-by-frame process. If it truly streamlines rendering and exporting without a steep learning curve, it could be better than doing it all by hand. But if it introduces new technical hurdles or isn't compatible with my tablet setup, I'd stick with my current manual method. Given it's open source, I'd pay $0 per month.

Simulated interest: 40/100

Daria Jarosneutral

Currently, I use Krita for sketching and Synfig for vector clean-up and animation. Doing it by hand is just too time-consuming for my workflow. Pencil2D's claim of seamless raster and vector is interesting, but I'm concerned about its depth compared to my current tools. The biggest draw for Pencil2D would be if it significantly simplified my workflow, perhaps by combining Krita and Synfig's capabilities into one intuitive package. However, since Pencil2D is open source and free, I wouldn't pay a subscription. My current tools are free, and I'm very budget-conscious, so adopting a paid tool would need to offer a substantial advantage.

Donnie Denesikneutral

Right now, my team and I primarily use a mix of free animation tools and manual slide-based storyboards for our microlearning videos. I often do the actual drawing myself to fill in the gaps. Pencil2D being open-source and free is definitely appealing, especially given our startup budget. The "Raster & Vector" capability sounds useful for sketching and then refining. What would make it better than my current workflow is if it significantly speeds up the animation process and reduces the manual drawing I have to do, without sacrificing quality or brand consistency. What would make it worse is if it has a steep learning curve, or if it's not stable. I'd stick with my current tools if Pencil2D doesn't offer a clear efficiency gain or introduces too much complexity.

Simulated interest: 50/100

Lucrezia Pinardineutral

Currently, I use open-source apps like Krita and Pencil2D, along with a spreadsheet and notebook, to manage my work. The fact that Pencil2D is described as open-source and free is very appealing to me, as I'm always looking for cost-effective solutions. If it offers the seamless raster and vector capabilities it mentions, and is as lightweight and intuitive as claimed, it could be a good fit. However, my current workflow is already quite established with the tools I know. I'd need to see if Pencil2D offers something significantly better for my animation loops or comic panel work than what I'm already using. Since it's open-source and free, I wouldn't pay for it.

Gitanjali Desaineutral

Right now, I'm using a bunch of free tools cobbled together – think Inkscape for vectors, maybe Krita or even just basic drawing apps for the hand-drawn bits. It's a whole workflow. If Pencil2D could seamlessly integrate both vector and raster, like it claims, that would be a big plus. The fact that it's open source and free is already a massive win. Honestly, I'd rather contribute to open-source projects than pay for software I barely use. What would make it better is perhaps more advanced animation controls or better performance on older hardware, but honestly, being free keeps me on my current stack for now. I wouldn't pay for it.

Simulated interest: 0/100

Keep exploring.

Find your next question or see which topics divide AI panels.

Keep exploring

What would you ask next?

Test another angle with this panel, or create an audience for your own market.