What do you use today instead of Mana Grove (https://themanagrove.com/) (a competitor, a spreadsheet, doing it by hand)? Compared with that, what would make Mana Grove better or worse for you, and what would keep you on your current option? Also say the maximum you would pay per month in USD (0 if nothing).
Page reviewed
Mana Grove deck builder and AI deck assistant for Commander
https://themanagrove.com/ (opens in a new tab)
10 fictional AI personas. Exploratory perspectives, not a survey of real customers. Methodology & limitations
Simulated interest
AI synthesis, not measured demand
Suggested price range
Median $2.5 · simulated willingness to pay
Response sentiment
What this panel suggests
The main barrier in this batch is not a negative product verdict but an access problem: respondents said they could not reach the Mana Grove site, so they could not actually compare it with their current setup. Their current substitutes are mostly free or manual workflows: spreadsheets, Google Docs, ring binders, and established deck builders such as Moxfield or Archidekt. What would make Mana Grove better is not abstract branding, but a concrete advantage over those options—especially faster deck building, better card discovery, or AI help that clearly saves time. What would keep them on the current option is simple: it already works, costs nothing, and preserves their existing workflow. The page claims a free Commander deck builder with AI tools, and respondents did not dispute that in use; rather, they could not evaluate it due to access. That means the feedback is mostly a clarity and accessibility signal, not a feature rejection. Pricing tolerance is very low, with the reported range centered around a few dollars per month, so any paid tier would need to feel optional and obviously valuable.
Pricing & positioning
Do not assume strong paid demand from this batch. The clearest pattern is that respondents want to keep using free tools unless Mana Grove clearly outperforms them, especially through Grover/Scry saving time or improving deck decisions. A strong free tier remains important. If monetized, a very low-priced premium tier is more plausible than a higher subscription.
The reported willingness to pay is very low overall, with a median of $2.50/month and a high of $5/month. That suggests a pricing ceiling that is modest, and likely only for features that feel materially better than spreadsheets, manual notes, or existing deck builders. The access-block issue also means this batch does not cleanly test pricing or feature value.
Recurring themes
“I can't access the Mana Grove website to evaluate it; I'm currently blocked.”Read Jesse Gorczany’s response →
“I'm currently using Google Docs and a ring binder for my deck notes, which works fine for me.”Read Jacqueline McCullough’s response →
“I wouldn't pay a monthly subscription without seeing a significant, demonstrable benefit over my existing, free tools.”Read Jesse Gorczany’s response →
Objections to investigate
- Blocked access / unable to evaluate the site
- Satisfied with free alternatives like spreadsheets, Moxfield, Archidekt, or manual notes
- Needs obvious time-saving or better deck insights to justify switching
- Reluctance to pay monthly for a hobby tool
- Concern about moving away from an established workflow
Use these findings to plan customer interviews or experiments. How to interpret AI research
What the panel said
Click a name to open that persona’s full profile.
Jesse GorczanyneutralI can't access the Mana Grove website to evaluate it; I'm currently blocked. I use a personal spreadsheet, Moxfield, and Scryfall to manage my decks, tracking mana bases and curves. If Mana Grove offered superior data analysis or AI assistance that genuinely saved me time and provided deeper insights than my current system, it would be compelling. However, without being able to access the site, I can't assess its features or value proposition. I'd be willing to consider a free trial, but I wouldn't pay a monthly subscription without seeing a significant, demonstrable benefit over my existing, free tools. If a paid plan were to offer advanced analytics and AI that truly optimized my deck building process, I might consider up to $5 per month.
Simulated interest: 20/100
Jacqueline McCulloughneutralI'm currently using Google Docs and a ring binder for my deck notes, which works fine for me. I can't access Mana Grove right now as I'm blocked from the site, so I can't really tell you what would make it better or worse. I'm generally hesitant to pay for tools when free alternatives exist, especially given my budget. If I could access it and it saved me a significant amount of time, I might consider paying up to $0 per month.
Simulated interest: 0/100
Gajaadhar MahajanneutralI can't actually access the Mana Grove website because it says I've been blocked. Right now, I use a very detailed spreadsheet for my four Commander decks, tracking land counts, budgets, and potential card swaps. It works well for me because it's entirely customizable and I have full control. If Mana Grove could offer advanced statistical analysis beyond just land counts, or perhaps an AI that could suggest budget-friendly upgrades based on my existing card pool, that might be compelling. However, without being able to see the actual product, it's hard to say. I'm not willing to pay for a subscription service for this, especially since my current spreadsheet method is free and effective for my needs.
Simulated interest: 0/100
Tammo SewaldneutralI am currently unable to access the Mana Grove website due to a block. Therefore, I cannot evaluate its features or compare it to my current method of using spreadsheets and handwritten notes for my Commander decks. My process is meticulous and I prefer to understand things myself. Without being able to access the product, I cannot determine what would make it better or worse than my existing system, nor can I estimate any potential value or cost. I would need to access the site to provide any meaningful feedback.
Phyllis HammesneutralI'm currently using Archidekt to manage my Commander decks, which works well for organizing my ideas and sharing them with my playgroup. The page for Mana Grove is blocked, so I can't actually see what it offers or how it compares. Without being able to access it, I can't say what would make it better or worse for me, or what would keep me on Archidekt. If I could access it and it offered significantly better features for tracking card prices and synergies, I might consider it. However, given my budget, I wouldn't pay more than $0 per month for a deck building tool right now.
Simulated interest: 0/100
Anatole ColinnegativeI can't access the Mana Grove website at all; it says I've been blocked. Before this, I was using a combination of Moxfield, Scryfall, and a very detailed private spreadsheet to manage our YouTube channel's deck ideas and notes. What would make Mana Grove better for me would be a seamless integration with my current workflow and the ability to easily cross-reference data points like mana curves and ban list changes, something my spreadsheet handles meticulously. The biggest barrier to switching, besides this access issue, would be the sheer amount of manual migration required to replicate my existing data. I wouldn't pay for a tool I can't even access right now.
Simulated interest: 0/100
Joy van BeekneutralI'm currently using a shared Google Sheet to keep track of our Commander pod's decks, house rules, and upgrade notes. I also rely on free card-search sites and forum posts for interaction ideas. The ability to search cards by what they do, as mentioned on Mana Grove's page, sounds very useful for quickly finding synergies, which is a current pain point for me. However, I can't actually access the site right now because I'm blocked. If I could access it and it streamlined deck analysis and synergy research significantly, I might consider a small subscription, perhaps up to $5 per month, but I'd need to see how it fits into my current workflow and budget first.
Simulated interest: 30/100
Bobby Larkin-BergnaumneutralUnfortunately, I can't even access the Mana Grove website because I'm being blocked. So, I can't tell you what I use now, what would make it better or worse, or what keeps me on my current option. I'm currently using a mix of spreadsheets and just keeping notes in my binders for deckbuilding. If I could access it and it offered features beyond what I'm doing now, I might consider it, but without being able to see it, I can't say. I'd need to see the pricing first, but given my budget, I'd probably only pay around $5 per month if it was truly a significant upgrade.
Stephen WhiteneutralI can't actually access the Mana Grove website you linked; it says I've been blocked, which is a bit frustrating. Right now, I use a spreadsheet and keep notes in a text file for my decks on Moxfield. If I could access it, I'd be looking for features that simplify tracking card values and potential swaps, as that's a big part of my budget optimisation. The AI assistant sounds interesting, but honestly, the blocking issue makes it impossible to say what would make it better or worse, or what would keep me on my current methods. I'm not willing to pay for anything until I can actually use it, so it's $0 per month.
Shashi TagoreneutralI can't access the Mana Grove website because I've been blocked, so I'm unable to compare it to my current method of using free tools and spreadsheets for deckbuilding. I would need to be able to access and evaluate the features, especially the AI assistant, to determine its value. Since I prefer free or cost-effective solutions, if it offers significant advantages over what I use now, I might consider a subscription. However, without access, I can't estimate a price. My current setup works well for my needs.
Keep exploring.
Find your next question or see which topics divide AI panels.
What would you ask next?
Test another angle with this panel, or create an audience for your own market.