What would stop you from trying MakerTime (https://www.makertime.ai/) this month? Be specific about how you handle this today. Also say the maximum you would pay per month in USD (0 if nothing).
Page reviewed
MakerTime — Quantify Your Deep Work And Defeat Distractions
https://www.makertime.ai/ (opens in a new tab)
10 fictional AI personas. Exploratory perspectives, not a survey of real customers. Methodology & limitations
Simulated interest
AI synthesis, not measured demand
Suggested price range
Median $15 · simulated willingness to pay
Response sentiment
What this panel suggests
The dominant reason these respondents would not try MakerTime this month is simple access friction: the app requires macOS on Apple Silicon, which makes it unavailable to many people before they can even evaluate the features. Several respondents described their current approach as good enough for now, using manual spreadsheets, Notion, Toggl, or other trackers to record focus time and billable hours. That means the product is competing against established routines, not a blank slate. Privacy and local processing were viewed positively, especially the idea that data stays on-device, but that benefit did not offset the platform barrier. A smaller secondary concern is pricing uncertainty around a future paid tier. For the subset that could imagine paying later, the maximum monthly amount was modest, around the low-to-mid teens at most. Overall, the responses suggest that compatibility, setup clarity, and trust are the gating issues this month; price is a follow-on question rather than the core objection.
Pricing & positioning
Keep the alpha free while the product is still gated by macOS/Apple Silicon. If you introduce a paid tier, make the entry price modest and preserve an early-adopter discount so compatible users can test it without much risk.
The main obstacle this month is access, not price. For the subset that is open to paying later, the stated ceiling clusters around the low-teens per month, with some only comfortable at a very low single-digit price. Price clarity matters, but compatibility and installation friction matter more right now.
Recurring themes
“Currently, I'm tracking focus blocks manually in a spreadsheet and Notion”Read Omar Stiedemann-Runolfsson’s response →
“I appreciate the commitment to privacy”Read Eva Jones’s response →
Objections to investigate
- Operating system restriction (macOS only / Apple Silicon requirement)
- Existing free or adequate alternatives are already in use
- Uncertainty about future pricing and paid tiers
Use these findings to plan customer interviews or experiments. How to interpret AI research
What the panel said
Click a name to open that persona’s full profile.
Omar Stiedemann-RunolfssonneutralThe primary concern would be its compatibility with my current setup. I'm on a Windows machine for most of my development work, but I do have a MacBook Pro for testing specific aspects. The note about requiring macOS with Apple Silicon is a significant hurdle, as not all my work happens there. Currently, I'm tracking focus blocks manually in a spreadsheet and Notion, which is rudimentary but functional. Given that the alpha version is free, I'd be willing to try it without any cost, but I wouldn't pay for a future tier until I'm certain it integrates seamlessly and provides demonstrably better insights than my current method. I'd pay $15 per month for a future paid tier if it proved essential.
Simulated interest: 70/100
Glenda Bahringer-BernierneutralThe primary obstacle to trying MakerTime this month is the stated requirement for MacOS with Apple Silicon. I use a Windows machine for work. Currently, I'm manually auditing my screen activity with RescueTime and using rigid calendar blocks to manage my focus time. My private spreadsheet complements this by tracking personal progress. Since the alpha version is free, I'd be willing to test it if the OS compatibility were not an issue. If it were available for Windows, I'd consider paying up to $10 per month for a future, stable version.
Simulated interest: 30/100
Lennie SchondelmaiernegativeThe primary concern for me would be its compatibility with my current workflow. I use a mix of Linux and Windows machines for client work, and the "Note (Jan 2025): Requires MacOS w/ Apple Silicon" immediately flags it as incompatible. Furthermore, while the emphasis on privacy is excellent, I already meticulously log my billable hours in Toggl and a separate encrypted spreadsheet due to client restrictions on desktop logging. Introducing another tool that observes my screen, even locally, might complicate reporting and auditing processes. The alpha version is free, so there's no immediate cost barrier, but the platform limitation and potential workflow disruption are significant obstacles.
Simulated interest: 0/100
Malati DubashineutralRight now, the biggest hurdle to trying MakerTime is that it requires MacOS with Apple Silicon, and I'm on a Windows machine. If it were cross-platform, I'd definitely be interested. My current method for tracking focus time involves exporting data from Clockify and then manually reconciling it in a shared Google Sheet, which is quite a bit of administrative overhead. The idea of an AI-powered tool that analyzes screen activity for deep work is intriguing, especially the privacy aspect since data never leaves the machine. If it were compatible with my system, I'd be willing to pay up to $15 per month for a tool like this to streamline my focus time tracking and gain better insights.
Simulated interest: 70/100
Sidney TorphyneutralMy current tool, Rize, already helps me segment my deep work from administrative tasks, and I find its daily summaries useful for my Friday retrospectives. MakerTime's focus on screen analysis and local LLMs is interesting, but I'm not sure it offers a significantly different value proposition beyond what I already have. Also, the requirement for MacOS with Apple Silicon is a blocker, as I use a Windows machine for work. The alpha version being free is a plus, but if a paid tier were introduced, I'd likely be willing to pay up to $15 per month, provided it genuinely improved my focus beyond Rize.
Simulated interest: 50/100
Charlotte CornelissenneutralRight now, what would stop me from trying MakerTime this month is the requirement for MacOS with Apple Silicon, as my current work machine is Windows. I currently handle tracking my focused hours using Toggl, and then I manually cross-reference those hours with my detailed project notes in Notion to plan my next research steps. It's a process that works well for me, though it's certainly manual. Since the alpha is free, I don't have a price in mind. However, if it were to become a paid product in the future, I might consider up to $15 per month.
Simulated interest: 30/100
Ernesto DonnellyneutralThe primary thing stopping me from trying MakerTime this month is that it requires macOS with Apple Silicon, and I'm currently on a Windows machine. My current method for tracking time involves a meticulous spreadsheet combined with a free online stopwatch, which I update manually after each task. It's a bit of a chore, but it works for me. If it were compatible, I'd be willing to pay up to $5 per month for such a tool, given my income and preference for low-cost solutions.
Simulated interest: 30/100
Eleonora KosnegativeThe main thing stopping me is the requirement for MacOS with Apple Silicon, as I'm currently using a Windows machine for work. Also, the manual time logging, while sometimes tedious, is integrated into my current workflow with Asana and my calendar. If it were compatible, I might consider a price around $10-$15 per month, but since it's not compatible, I wouldn't pay anything.
Simulated interest: 0/100
Marut MehrotraneutralMy primary concern is the macOS requirement. I use a Windows machine for development, so MakerTime wouldn't be compatible with my current setup. Even if I were on a Mac, the fact that the alpha is free and future pricing is TBD makes it hard to commit to a monthly cost. I currently track my own coding sessions using ActivityWatch and spreadsheets, and that system, while manual, is already integrated into my sprint planning with Pranav. I don't see a compelling reason to switch without knowing the future cost structure or if it offers a significant improvement over my existing, free methods.
Eva JonesneutralThis tool sounds intriguing, particularly the AI-powered analysis of screen activity to quantify deep work. Right now, I meticulously track my uninterrupted work using calendar blocks and my paper notebook, which helps me understand my output. The idea of automating that insight is appealing, and I appreciate the commitment to privacy. However, my current system is functional and cost-free. The note about requiring macOS with Apple Silicon is also a potential hurdle, as I'm not sure if my current setup meets that specification. I'd need to verify compatibility before considering it. If it works seamlessly and provides truly actionable insights that surpass my current methods, I might consider a nominal fee.
Simulated interest: 30/100
Keep exploring.
Find your next question or see which topics divide AI panels.
What would you ask next?
Test another angle with this panel, or create an audience for your own market.