What do you use today instead of MakeDecks (https://makedecks.com/) (a competitor, a spreadsheet, doing it by hand)? Compared with that, what would make MakeDecks better or worse for you, and what would keep you on your current option? Also say the maximum you would pay per month in USD (0 if nothing).
Page reviewed
MakeDecks: free AI presentation maker and PPT generator
https://makedecks.com/ (opens in a new tab)
10 fictional AI personas. Exploratory perspectives, not a survey of real customers. Methodology & limitations
Simulated interest
AI synthesis, not measured demand
Suggested price range
Median $15 · simulated willingness to pay
Response sentiment
What this panel suggests
Most respondents said they currently use a manual or hybrid workflow instead of MakeDecks: Google Slides, PowerPoint, and combinations of Gamma and Canva. The main appeal of MakeDecks is not novelty; it is reducing the time spent turning rough inputs into a usable deck. Respondents repeatedly framed the win as faster initial structuring, especially if the output stays editable and does not require reformatting afterward. Several said the deciding factor would be whether the generated PPTX is genuinely native and easy to modify in PowerPoint or Google Slides. The biggest hesitations were about complex data, accuracy, and brand fit. People want confidence that charts, figures, and typography survive the conversion cleanly, especially for client- or board-facing work. Some concerns reflect a possible perception gap versus the page claims, which say the app preserves numbers exactly, supports editable charts, and opens in PowerPoint, Keynote, and Google Slides. Pricing expectations were modest: the sample’s max willingness to pay centered at $15/month, with a low-end anchor of $5 and a higher ceiling of $20 for stronger workflow fit and reliability.
Pricing & positioning
Keep a strong free tier for evaluation, then convert heavy users and teams to a paid plan around the stated market anchor.
Responses cluster around a low-to-moderate monthly ceiling, with the median at $15 and the high end at $20. The clearest value drivers are time saved, native editability, and reliable handling of spreadsheets/docs into usable slides.
Recurring themes
“Google Slides”Read Susie Cummings’s response →
“It's time-consuming, and I'm always looking for ways to streamline that process.”Read Susie Cummings’s response →
“The ability to edit the output in PowerPoint is key, as my team and I work heavily in Google Slides”Read Susie Cummings’s response →
“What I'd be concerned about is how well it handles complex data or if the AI-generated designs would align with our brand.”Read Susie Cummings’s response →
“if the AI-generated designs would align with our brand”Read Susie Cummings’s response →
Objections to investigate
- Complex data handling
- Loss of control/editing flexibility
- Brand alignment and design rigidity
- Workflow disruption
Use these findings to plan customer interviews or experiments. How to interpret AI research
What the panel said
Click a name to open that persona’s full profile.
Susie CummingspositiveRight now, I manually convert campaign notes, webinar transcripts, and KPI exports into presentations using Google Slides. It's time-consuming, and I'm always looking for ways to streamline that process. MakeDecks seems promising because it can turn raw data, like spreadsheets, directly into slides, which would save me a ton of time. The ability to edit the output in PowerPoint is key, as my team and I work heavily in Google Slides, but the ability to export a clean PPTX is valuable. What I'd be concerned about is how well it handles complex data or if the AI-generated designs would align with our brand. If it significantly reduces my manual effort and produces professional-looking decks, I could see myself using it. I'd be willing to pay up to $15 per month for a Pro plan if it meets those needs.
Simulated interest: 75/100
Domingo Rodriguez-LeschneutralCurrently, I draft initial structures in Gamma, then meticulously migrate and refine everything in PowerPoint. MakeDecks' ability to turn notes, spreadsheets, or even links directly into an editable deck sounds intriguing. The primary advantage over my current approach would be the time saved on initial structuring, potentially avoiding the Gamma step altogether. However, the critical factor for me is the fidelity of the output and how seamlessly it integrates into PowerPoint for final client delivery – especially maintaining brand compliance and precise typography. If the transition is smooth and the output is genuinely editable in PowerPoint without significant reformatting, it could be valuable. I'd need to see how it handles complex financial models from Excel. I'm willing to pay up to $20 per month for this.
Simulated interest: 50/100
Doreen LittleneutralRight now, I'm essentially doing this by hand in PowerPoint, piecing together notes and screenshots. The idea of automating that initial conversion is appealing, especially if it can pull data accurately from spreadsheets or notes and structure it quickly. However, I've found AI summarization tools often require more editing than they save. The biggest draw would be saving significant time on the initial draft, but I'd need to see if the output is actually faster to refine than starting from scratch. The editing capabilities, like asking for changes or switching layouts easily, sound useful. The free tier limits are a bit restrictive for a startup, but the Pro at $15/month seems reasonable if it truly streamlines the process. I'd consider paying up to $15 per month.
Simulated interest: 60/100
Bhasvan AgarwalneutralToday, my team and I manually convert release notes, customer calls, and Excel feature matrices into proposal decks, launch briefs, and sales enablement slides. We primarily use PowerPoint and Canva templates for this. MakeDecks' ability to turn any notes or files into an editable deck sounds promising, especially the spreadsheet conversion, as it could significantly reduce the manual formatting effort. However, I'd be concerned about the accuracy of data translation from Excel and the flexibility in customizing the final output to match our specific brand guidelines. The free tier offers a limited number of decks, and while the Pro version is priced at $15 a month, I would only consider paying up to $10 per month for this service.
Simulated interest: 40/100
Ilayda RoggatzpositiveCurrently, I manually compile our monthly leadership updates and quarterly reviews from Excel data exports and project notes directly into PowerPoint. The idea of turning disparate sources like spreadsheets into a designed deck quickly is appealing, especially the claim of "same facts, better slides." This could save significant time. However, my main concern would be the accuracy of the data translation from Excel. Ensuring the numbers are kept exact, as stated, is crucial. If it truly automates the slide creation with precise data, I would consider paying for a Pro subscription. I'm willing to pay $15 per month.
Simulated interest: 70/100
Anal MenonpositiveCurrently, I meticulously transform PDFs, notes, and screenshots into training decks using presentation software. It's a manual, though precise, process. MakeDecks sounds intriguing because it promises to automate much of this, especially turning raw documents into editable slides. The ability to quickly refine and restyle would be a significant time-saver. However, I'd need to ensure the AI accurately captures complex compliance details and that the output is truly editable for my specific needs. If it streamlines my workflow without sacrificing accuracy, it would be invaluable. I'd be willing to pay up to $15 per month.
Simulated interest: 75/100
Maximilien Le gallneutralCurrently, I rely on a combination of CRM exports, manual PowerPoint formatting, and shared Google Docs for creating pitch decks, role briefs, and client updates. The process is time-consuming and repetitive, but it’s familiar and ensures a level of control over the final product. I’ve also experimented with templates and basic automation tools in the past, but none have fully met my needs without requiring significant adjustments. MakeDecks seems promising because it could potentially streamline my workflow by turning notes, PDFs, and spreadsheets into polished decks quickly. However, I’d need to test it extensively to ensure it integrates well with our existing processes. If it can reduce the 2-3 hours I spend daily on formatting and still maintain the quality we deliver, it would be a significant time-saver. That said, I’m cautious about new tools disrupting my workflow. I would consider paying up to $20 per month for a tool that proves its value, but only if it consistently saves me time without requiring additional training or adjustments.
Simulated interest: 60/100
Carol KuhlmanneutralCurrently, I'm using PowerPoint directly, customizing templates I find online. The idea of turning notes or spreadsheets directly into a presentation is appealing, especially if it saves time. However, I'm concerned about how well it would capture the nuance of research data and if the editing would be truly flexible. My current process, while time-consuming, gives me complete control. If MakeDecks could guarantee accuracy and offer deep customization without losing the original data's integrity, it would be a significant improvement. But if it's more of a basic conversion, I'd stick with what I have. Given my stipend, I'm hesitant to spend much. I'd consider paying up to $5 per month if it truly streamlined my workflow and produced professional-looking slides efficiently.
Simulated interest: 40/100
Jonathan van GinnekenneutralI currently draft decks in Canva and refine them in PowerPoint, a workflow that gives me control but eats into my time. MakeDecks looks like it could speed this up by turning raw notes or spreadsheets into slide-ready formats. But I'd need to test if it handles workshop notes as well as I manually do—the details matter. The free tier is tempting for quick drafts, but I'd hit the 20-deck monthly limit. At €65k variable income, $15/month isn't a dealbreaker, but I'd need confidence it reduces my late-night editing marathons. If it lets me 'write first, design simpler,' I'd try it. Maximum I'd pay? $12/month, assuming no hidden onboarding costs.
Simulated interest: 70/100
Pat PowlowskipositiveRight now, I'm manually pulling data from support tickets and Excel sheets into Google Slides. It's time-consuming, especially when I have to format everything perfectly for QBRs or renewal briefs. MakeDecks sounds promising because it can directly convert spreadsheets and notes into designed slides, saving me significant time on the initial formatting and drafting. The ability to switch layouts and themes quickly is also appealing. What I'd need to see is how well it handles complex data, if the 'edits any slide' feature is truly seamless, and if it integrates with Google Slides easily, as that's my primary tool. If it genuinely streamlines my workflow and produces polished results with minimal effort, it could be a game-changer. I'd consider paying up to $20 per month.
Simulated interest: 75/100
Keep exploring.
Find your next question or see which topics divide AI panels.
What would you ask next?
Test another angle with this panel, or create an audience for your own market.