You land on https://getmentionedbyai.com (GetMentionedByAI) for the first time. What's unclear, what makes you leave, and what would make you sign up?
Page reviewed
AI Visibility & AEO Tools Directory — GetMentionedByAI
https://getmentionedbyai.com/ (opens in a new tab)
10 fictional AI personas. Exploratory perspectives, not a survey of real customers. Methodology & limitations
Simulated interest
AI synthesis, not measured demand
Suggested price range
No numeric price estimates in the answers. Ask a pricing follow-up to collect them.
Response sentiment
What this panel suggests
First-time visitors seem to see real utility in GetMentionedByAI’s core promise: a verified directory for AI visibility, AEO, and GEO tools. The page’s claim that it compares 200+ tools and records published prices, engine coverage, and capabilities without invented scores aligns with what buyers want. That said, the main friction is trust and speed of use. Respondents want a clearer explanation of what “verified” actually means beyond the statement that a human checked public pages, and they want to know how deep that verification goes. There’s also confusion about how to quickly find the right tool for a specific need, especially filtering by engines like ChatGPT, Perplexity, Gemini, or Claude and comparing options side by side. The prominent sponsored placements create some skepticism about objectivity, even though the page says sponsored slots are labeled and do not affect editorial verdicts. Overall, the concept is relevant, but clearer verification details and more obvious comparison/search flows would likely reduce drop-off and make sign-up or continued browsing more compelling.
Recurring themes
“What's unclear is the verification process beyond "humans checked vendor's public pages."”Read Vanessa Crist’s response →
“I'd leave because I'm looking for solutions to track brand mentions in AI, and it's not immediately obvious how to filter or search for that.”Read Dani de Koning’s response →
“The sponsored slots are also quite prominent, which makes me question the objectivity.”Read Constance Olivier’s response →
Objections to investigate
- Unclear verification methodology depth
- Inability to filter by specific AI engines (Perplexity, Gemini, etc.)
- Lack of side-by-side comparison capabilities on the directory page
- High cost perception of sponsored slots ($250-$500/mo)
Use these findings to plan customer interviews or experiments. How to interpret AI research
What the panel said
Click a name to open that persona’s full profile.
Vanessa CristneutralAs a Senior SEO Manager, I'm always looking for tools to track AI visibility, so this directory is immediately relevant. What's unclear is the verification process beyond "humans checked vendor's public pages." I need to understand the depth of that verification. Also, the pricing for some of the sponsored slots is high at $500/mo. What makes me leave is the lack of clear criteria for the "verified" badge and the potentially high cost for premium placements. What would make me sign up is a clearer explanation of the verification process, transparent pricing for all tools, and perhaps a free trial or freemium option for some of the basic AI visibility monitoring tools.
Simulated interest: 60/100
Ernesto KautzerneutralThe core value proposition is clear: a directory for AI visibility tools. However, the lack of specific engine coverage for each tool listed is a major gap for me. I spend hours manually checking this, so if I can't quickly see if a tool covers Perplexity or Gemini, it's less useful. The "verified badge" sounds promising, but without knowing the verification criteria, it's just another claim. What makes me leave is the immediate push to sponsor slots and the fact that I can't filter by specific AI engines or even by price tiers without clicking into each tool. To sign up, I'd need to see clear engine coverage, transparent pricing comparisons across all tools, and a way to filter by AI models like ChatGPT, Gemini, and Claude. A feature that allows comparing specific capabilities side-by-side without visiting each vendor's site would be a game-changer.
Simulated interest: 60/100
Nils CaspersneutralThe core concept of a directory for AI visibility tools is immediately clear and directly relevant to my work. What makes me hesitate is the lack of specific information on how these tools actually work beyond their listed capabilities. The "verified" badge is good, but I'd need to know the verification process is robust. To sign up, I'd need to see concrete examples or case studies of how specific tools have helped clients like mine improve their AI mention rates, especially for niche search terms. The "Ask AI" feature is intriguing, though.
Simulated interest: 40/100
Ahilya PandeyneutralThis directory seems like a good starting point for understanding the AI visibility landscape. I appreciate that it focuses on verified data rather than arbitrary scores. What's unclear is how the "verified badge" is applied – is it just a review of their website, or is there actual testing involved? The pricing for sponsored slots, starting from $250/mo, is a bit steep for my current team bandwidth and budget. However, if I could easily find tools to help demonstrate content's direct impact on conversions, I might consider signing up for a newsletter or exploring free tools.
Simulated interest: 30/100
Constance OlivierneutralThe core concept of a directory for AI visibility tools is immediately clear and relevant to my needs. However, I'm unsure how 'verified' listings are determined beyond a human checking public pages – I'd want to understand the depth of this verification. The sponsored slots are also quite prominent, which makes me question the objectivity. What would make me sign up? A transparent, detailed methodology for how each tool is evaluated, perhaps with case studies or deeper dives into specific functionalities. If the site offered a comparison feature that allowed me to directly contrast tools based on key criteria like engine coverage, pricing tiers (not just starting from), and specific features relevant to tracking client mentions across ChatGPT and Perplexity, I'd be very interested. The 'Ask AI' feature is intriguing, but without more context on its capabilities, it's hard to gauge its value.
Simulated interest: 75/100
Dani de KoningneutralIt's unclear how to actually *use* this directory to find a specific tool. I'd leave because I'm looking for solutions to track brand mentions in AI, and it's not immediately obvious how to filter or search for that. The page lists categories like 'Track AI visibility' and 'Improve AI visibility,' but without more context or a search function that understands my specific need, I'm unsure if it will actually help me compared to just manually testing prompts. What would make me sign up is a clear way to filter by specific AI models (like ChatGPT, Perplexity) and mention tracking capabilities, and perhaps some verified user reviews, not just sponsor slots.
Simulated interest: 30/100
Lance ReynoldsneutralThe core concept of tracking AI visibility and finding tools for that is interesting, especially given our focus on AI integration. However, the page feels a bit like a directory without much depth on how to *use* these tools effectively. It's unclear how GetMentionedByAI vets the tools beyond just checking public pages, and the lack of actual scores or ratings makes comparing them difficult. I'd leave because it's not immediately clear which tools are best suited for our specific needs in industrial software, and I'd need more than just a list. To sign up, I'd want to see case studies or more concrete data on tool effectiveness, perhaps a personalized recommendation engine, or at least clearer categories that align with business outcomes.
Ada WalkerneutralWhen I first land on GetMentionedByAI, I'd be looking for a clearer understanding of what "AEO" and "GEO" mean in this context. While the directory itself is interesting, the initial description of tools for "AI Visibility & AEO Tools Directory" is a bit vague. I would leave if I couldn't quickly ascertain if the tools listed could help me analyze how our firm's practice areas are being presented by AI, or if they offer source citation verification. To sign up, I'd want to see more concrete examples of how these tools have improved brand visibility or provided accurate source tracking for other legal firms, and perhaps a way to filter by specific legal practice areas.
Simulated interest: 40/100
Benigno FloreneutralInitially, the page feels a bit generic. I'm looking for specific tools to audit AI search visibility, and while this is a directory, it's not immediately clear how it filters or compares tools based on my ad hoc prompt analysis needs. The "verified directory" claim is good, but I'd need more than just a list of names and categories. What makes me hesitate is the lack of detail on *how* these tools actually work with AI models, beyond just tracking. To consider signing up for something here, I'd want to see a clear way to filter by specific AI models (like Gemini or Claude) and detailed feature breakdowns, perhaps even user reviews or case studies from consultants like myself. The sponsored slots are fine, but they shouldn't overshadow the core utility of finding actionable tools.
Simulated interest: 40/100
Matylda SzymkowiakneutralThe directory itself is clear enough, but the value proposition for a tool *like* this is the main question. I'm already using a competitor platform, and while this directory lists many tools, I'm unclear on how it directly helps me *improve* my AI visibility beyond just listing options. The "Sponsored" slots are a bit distracting, and the lack of specific details about engine coverage for each tool is a concern. I'd leave because I don't immediately see how it solves my core problem of proving AI visibility ROI to stakeholders. To sign up, I'd need to see a clear benefit over my current workflow, perhaps a unique comparison feature or a way to directly assess tool effectiveness for my specific needs.
Keep exploring.
Find your next question or see which topics divide AI panels.
What would you ask next?
Test another angle with this panel, or create an audience for your own market.