What do you use today instead of Forkest (https://www.forkest.dev/) (a competitor, a spreadsheet, doing it by hand)? Compared with that, what would make Forkest better or worse for you, and what would keep you on your current option? Also say the maximum you would pay per month in USD (0 if nothing).

10 fictional AI personas. Exploratory perspectives, not a survey of real customers. Methodology & limitations
Simulated interest
AI synthesis, not measured demand
Suggested price range
Median $1 · simulated willingness to pay
Response sentiment
What this panel suggests
Respondents mostly said they already rely on GitHub’s native contribution calendar, a spreadsheet, manual tracking, or a free widget instead of Forkest. The main comparison is not feature parity but usefulness: Forkest’s garden metaphor is seen as fun and visually distinctive, yet many people described it as a nice-to-have rather than something that replaces a real workflow tool. What would make it better is stronger public-facing value: a more attractive README/profile display, easier sharing, and anything that helps them showcase work or project identity. What would make it worse is if the paid layer feels like cosmetic decoration on top of data they already get for free from GitHub. The current option remains attractive when users just want raw contribution tracking, already have a spreadsheet habit, or are satisfied with a free widget. Willingness to pay is limited; the reported ceiling sits in low single digits per month, with some at zero. Overall sentiment is mostly neutral, with interest driven by novelty rather than urgency.
Pricing & positioning
Keep the core experience free and treat paid features as optional personalization for users who care about profile aesthetics, README decoration, or leaderboard visibility. The strongest fit looks like developers who enjoy showcasing activity publicly rather than people looking for a workflow tool. Validate whether any Pro feature creates enough status or branding value to justify a recurring fee.
Observed willingness to pay is low and concentrated in the low single digits per month, with some respondents at $0. A monthly price around $4 looks like an upper bound for this audience batch; lower-priced or one-time options may fit better than a heavy subscription pitch.
Recurring themes
“The idea of a garden growing with commits is novel.”Read Sherman Kub’s response →
“I currently track my GitHub commits in a personal spreadsheet alongside my goals.”Read Laureen Floder’s response →
Objections to investigate
- Lack of tangible workflow value
- Perception as purely cosmetic
- Sufficiency of free GitHub data
Use these findings to plan customer interviews or experiments. How to interpret AI research
What the panel said
Click a name to open that persona’s full profile.
Sherman KubneutralRight now, I track my GitHub contributions primarily by looking at my contribution calendar directly on GitHub, and I save screenshots of my streaks for my own records, especially for performance reviews. I also have a few notes where I log significant commits or project milestones. Forkest seems like an interesting visual representation of that data. The idea of a garden growing with commits is novel. Compared to my current method, it could make tracking streaks more engaging, and the public visibility might add a fun competitive element. However, I'm not sure how it handles project-specific contributions versus just overall activity. The core functionality of visualizing my public contribution calendar is already available for free on GitHub. The "Pro" features like the forest widget, animals, and custom colors are nice-to-haves, but not essential for my needs. Given that the free tier offers the basic garden visualization, I wouldn't pay for it. The $4 per month seems a bit steep for what is essentially a visual novelty on top of existing free data.
Simulated interest: 20/100
Lynda RitchienegativeRight now, I don't use anything like Forkest. My GitHub contributions are logged, and that's enough for me. I track my work and projects in Trello and keep my code in GitHub. Seeing my contributions as a garden sounds… whimsical, but I'm not sure it offers practical value for my workflow. I prefer to focus my energy on building client sites rather than visualising my commit history. The idea of it changing with the seasons is interesting, but it doesn't solve any problems I currently have. I wouldn't pay for this.
Simulated interest: 0/100
Triloki SutharpositiveRight now, I'm just using screenshots of my GitHub contribution graph for updates on my profile. I don't really track streaks or anything like that manually. Forkest seems interesting because it visualizes the contributions, which could be a cool way to show progress, especially for the SaaS project. The free tier is great, and honestly, the $4 a month for Pro is really appealing. It's a small price for something that adds a nice visual flair. I wouldn't want to pay more than $4 per month for this, though.
Simulated interest: 75/100
Laureen FloderneutralI currently track my GitHub commits in a personal spreadsheet alongside my goals. Compared to that, Forkest seems like a more visual and engaging way to see my activity. The idea of my commits growing a garden is quite unique. However, I'm not sure if the 'Pro' features like animals or personalized colors are essential for me. The main thing that would keep me using my spreadsheet is its direct link to my personal development goals, which Forkest doesn't seem to address. For the Pro version, I'd be willing to pay around $1 per month.
Simulated interest: 30/100
Patrick WalshneutralRight now, I'm tracking my GitHub activity using a spreadsheet and manual notes. It's functional, but definitely time-consuming. The idea of visualizing my contributions as a garden is interesting, and the free tier seems like a good starting point to see if it provides any real value beyond what I'm doing now. However, I'm skeptical about how much practical benefit it offers for my professional credibility. My GitHub activity is just one signal among many. If the Pro features, like the forest widget or seasonal drops, added tangible value, perhaps, but I'm not convinced they would. I'd be hesitant to pay for something that feels purely cosmetic. For now, I'd stick with my current method unless Forkest could demonstrably improve my workflow or provide insights I don't already have. I would not pay for this.
Simulated interest: 10/100
Théodora LerouxneutralCurrently, I don't use anything to visualize my GitHub activity beyond the contribution calendar itself. The idea of Forkest is intriguing; it transforms code commits into a visual garden, which is quite unique. It seems like a more engaging way to represent my contributions than just a spreadsheet or manual tracking. The "Pro" features like animals or a bench are charming, but I'm not sure they add significant value for me personally. The biggest draw would be the visual representation and perhaps the leaderboard for a bit of friendly competition. However, I'm hesitant to commit financially unless there's a clearer benefit to my workflow or personal projects. The pricing is quite accessible, starting at $4 a month, but I'd need to see how it integrates with my current profile README generator. For now, I would pay $0.
Simulated interest: 20/100
Marion LehnerneutralCurrently, I don't use anything beyond my own GitHub commits, which I sometimes manually log or assemble screenshots for personal progress tracking. Forkest's premise of visualizing commit activity as a garden is novel, and the free tier seems to offer basic functionality. However, I'm unclear on how the 'Forest widget' or 'Animals on your best days' in the Pro tier would practically benefit my work. My current method, while manual, gives me precise control. The automated nature of Forkest is appealing, but I'd need to see a more tangible benefit beyond aesthetics to justify a cost. For now, I’d stick to my current methods.
Simulated interest: 20/100
Victoria Frami-BergeneutralToday, I'm using a free widget that displays my GitHub contribution graph on my portfolio. It's basic but functional. Forkest's garden visualization is definitely more engaging and aesthetically pleasing than a static graph. I also appreciate that it updates automatically every 4 hours, which is better than me manually updating my current widget. The seasonal changes are a neat touch. However, I'm not sure if the Pro features like the forest widget, animals, or custom colors are worth the cost for me personally. My current widget is free, and while it's less visually appealing, it serves the purpose of showing my activity. I'd need to see how the Pro features actually enhance the narrative of my contributions before committing to a paid plan. I would consider paying up to $4 per month for the Pro features if they significantly added to my personal brand narrative or provided a unique visual storytelling element that my current free option lacks.
Simulated interest: 60/100
Deependra MahajanneutralRight now, I just use my GitHub contribution calendar directly, or sometimes I'll pull data into a spreadsheet if I need to analyze it for something specific. I don't really use anything else for tracking that. Forkest looks visually interesting, like a fun gamified way to see my activity, but I'm not sure it offers much beyond what I already see on GitHub. The idea of it growing with commits is neat, and I like that it's free forever for the basic features. The Pro features like animals and the forest widget sound like neat extras, but not something I'd pay for. I wouldn't pay anything per month for this service.
Johanna MolneutralCurrently, I just track my GitHub commits in a simple spreadsheet for my own records. It's very basic, but it's free and serves its purpose. Forkest seems like a fun, visual way to see my activity grow, almost like a game. The idea of my commits watering a garden is quite appealing. However, I'm not sure I need this level of visualization, and my current spreadsheet is sufficient for my needs. I also wonder how much effort it is to maintain the garden over time. For now, the free tier of Forkest is enough for me to explore, and I wouldn't pay for this kind of feature given my budget and current priorities. If I had to put a number on it, maybe $0 per month.
Simulated interest: 30/100
Keep exploring.
Find your next question or see which topics divide AI panels.
What would you ask next?
Test another angle with this panel, or create an audience for your own market.