What do you use today instead of DisconfirmAI (https://disconfirmai.com/en) (a competitor, a spreadsheet, doing it by hand)? Compared with that, what would make DisconfirmAI better or worse for you, and what would keep you on your current option? Also say the maximum you would pay per month in USD (0 if nothing).
Page reviewed
DisconfirmAI | Understand AI. Research investment opportunities.
https://disconfirmai.com/en (opens in a new tab)
10 fictional AI personas. Exploratory perspectives, not a survey of real customers. Methodology & limitations
Simulated interest
AI synthesis, not measured demand
Suggested price range
Median $50 · simulated willingness to pay
Response sentiment
What this panel suggests
Prospects mainly use spreadsheets, Notion/shared documents, and direct manual reading of SEC filings, earnings calls, annual reports, sell-side notes, and public web sources. DisconfirmAI looks attractive because it promises a more organized way to gather AI-investing material and, more importantly, to test a view against counter-evidence. That disconfirmation angle resonates with their desire for capital discipline and filtering hype. Compared with current workflows, it would be better if it saved time, kept original sources visible, and helped them stay current without having to compile everything by hand. It would be worse if the AI analysis felt shallow, inaccurate, or too automated relative to their own verification standards. The biggest reasons to stay with the current option are trust, granular control, and familiarity with manual processes. Pricing is also a clear concern because the offer is not yet fully transparent. The synthetic willingness-to-pay data spans $25 to $150 per month, with a median of $50, suggesting some room for paid tiers if the product proves useful and credible.
Pricing & positioning
Test a simple tiered subscription anchored around clear time savings: a low-friction entry tier for readers who mainly want curated AI/investing reading, and a higher tier for active research, tracking, and framework workflows. The main buying trigger appears to be replacing manual spreadsheet/Notion-heavy research without sacrificing verification.
Pricing uncertainty is a meaningful objection, so make the value ladder explicit early. Keep the public reading layer free, but put saved research, tracking, and deeper research tools behind paid tiers. Emphasize source trails, reviewability, and the ability to keep manual control rather than fully automating decisions.
Recurring themes
“Currently, I rely on spreadsheets and manual compilation of earnings calls, SEC filings, and news.”Read Joel Fahey’s response →
“DisconfirmAI's promise of gathering and structuring AI investment items is intriguing, especially the "counter-evidence" aspect that aligns with my capital discipline.”Read Dev Joshi’s response →
“However, the 'Research' function's claim of analyzing filings and pulling data needs more clarity on its depth and accuracy compared to my current methods.”Read Joel Fahey’s response →
Objections to investigate
- Unclear Pricing Structure
- Depth and Accuracy of AI Analysis
- Integration with Existing Workflows
- Loss of Granular Control
Use these findings to plan customer interviews or experiments. How to interpret AI research
What the panel said
Click a name to open that persona’s full profile.
Joel FaheyneutralCurrently, I rely on spreadsheets and manual compilation of earnings calls, SEC filings, and news. DisconfirmAI's promise of gathering and organizing this information, especially its 'skim layer' and 'short essay' approach, sounds efficient. The ability to track companies and themes and have it report changes is appealing. However, the 'Research' function's claim of analyzing filings and pulling data needs more clarity on its depth and accuracy compared to my current methods. The pricing isn't clear, but if the research and tracking features are as robust as they seem, I might consider paying up to $50 per month.
Simulated interest: 40/100
Allison HagenesneutralCurrently, I manually aggregate information from annual reports, sell-side notes, and public web sources into shared documents. DisconfirmAI's promise of gathering AI and investing items, allowing deeper dives into original material, and testing views with new evidence sounds appealing. It could potentially save me significant time by filtering out noise and organizing information more efficiently. However, I'd need to understand how it handles the verification of sources and the depth of its "research" capabilities to ensure it meets my rigorous standards. The idea of an "AI agent" is intriguing, but I'm cautious about relying too heavily on AI without human oversight. My primary concern is accuracy and the ability to cross-reference data effectively. If it genuinely streamlines my workflow without compromising quality, I might consider it. I would need to see the pricing details, but for a tool that could save me hours of manual work each week, I might be willing to pay up to $150 per month.
Simulated interest: 60/100
Dev JoshineutralCurrently, I rely on a combination of Crunchbase, X threads, and company filings, all meticulously organized in Notion and Google Sheets. This manual process allows me full control and deep dives into specific data points. DisconfirmAI's promise of gathering and structuring AI investment items is intriguing, especially the "counter-evidence" aspect that aligns with my capital discipline. However, I'd need to see how it handles the sheer volume and ensures the "skim layer" isn't just noise, and if its "research" capabilities truly go beyond what I can extract myself. If it significantly reduces my research time without sacrificing depth or accuracy, it could be valuable. I'm cautious about automated analysis and prefer to verify sources myself. Given the cost is in USD, and my income is in INR, I'd need to evaluate the exchange rate and my actual disposable income for such investments. I'd pay around $25 per month.
Simulated interest: 60/100
Sean MöcksneutralCurrently, I rely on a combination of a professional market data platform, extensive manual reading of research papers and industry publications, and my internal spreadsheets to track AI infrastructure, software, and semiconductor companies. DisconfirmAI's "Reading" and "Research" features, particularly the ability to gather and analyze information from public sources with an emphasis on counter-evidence, seem promising for supplementing my current process. The "Radar" function for monitoring specific companies or themes also appeals to my need for continuous updates. However, I would need to see how well it integrates with or replaces my existing data feeds and how efficiently it handles the sheer volume of information I process daily. The core value proposition of testing investment theses against opposing evidence is compelling, but its practical application and the depth of analysis it provides, compared to my rigorous manual vetting, are key questions. I am uncertain about the pricing for the full suite of features; I would consider paying up to $100 per month if it demonstrably saves me significant time and enhances the quality of my research, but I would need more clarity on the subscription tiers and what exactly is included.
Simulated interest: 60/100
Astrée Da silvaneutralCurrently, I rely on a combination of Google Docs, browser tabs, and our shared CRM to gather counterpoints and market evidence. Doing this manually or with spreadsheets is time-consuming. DisconfirmAI's promise of AI-driven counter-evidence and structured research seems appealing, potentially saving significant time. However, I'd need to understand how it handles deep-tech specifics and integrates with our workflow. What would keep me on my current option is the familiarity and flexibility of my existing tools, especially given our fund's size and less formal research stack. I would be willing to pay up to $50 per month.
Simulated interest: 40/100
Rickey HaagneutralCurrently, I rely on extensive spreadsheet work and manual compilation of data, supplemented by public filings and earnings call transcripts, to maintain my AI equity framework. The core of my process involves rigorous verification, often taking days for a single data point. DisconfirmAI's promise of AI-assisted research and keeping understanding current is appealing, particularly the idea of testing views against counter-evidence. However, I'm cautious about its ability to replace the granular control and deep dive verification I perform manually. The lack of explicit detail on how it handles the nuances of early-stage AI valuation and the depth of its data verification process is a concern. My current methods are time-consuming but provide absolute clarity, which is paramount. I would need to see a clear demonstration of how DisconfirmAI enhances, rather than compromises, this level of rigor. Given the nature of my research and my current income, I would be willing to pay a maximum of $30 per month, contingent on its proven ability to support my existing framework without introducing ambiguity.
Simulated interest: 40/100
Dolores HarrisneutralCurrently, I rely on a combination of an existing AI research workspace, Excel, and Bloomberg for my analysis. DisconfirmAI's focus on testing views and surfacing counter-evidence seems promising, potentially addressing my problem of information overload and discerning hype from genuine innovation. The structured annotation types and the 'Radar' feature for tracking changes could be beneficial. However, the pricing model isn't clear from the provided information. If it offers a robust way to quickly identify dissenting data and streamline synthesis, I might consider it, but I'd need more clarity on the costs. My current tools, while imperfect, are integrated into my workflow. I would be willing to pay up to $75 per month, provided the platform demonstrably improves my team's efficiency and the accuracy of our theses.
Simulated interest: 60/100
Ramiro Zavala MesaneutralCurrently, I rely on a combination of manual review of filings, earnings transcripts, and sell-side research. I also use spreadsheets to organize data. For DisconfirmAI to be better, it would need to demonstrate a clear advantage in speed and accuracy in cross-validating AI claims against primary sources. The risk is that it introduces more noise or requires significant effort to integrate into my existing workflow. I would need to see how it handles the volume of claims and the nuances of financial reporting before considering payment. The pricing basis is unclear, but for a tool like this, I might consider paying up to $75 per month if it proves its value.
Simulated interest: 40/100
Kim PurdyneutralCurrently, I rely on free news sources, quarterly reports, and my own spreadsheet to track AI infrastructure companies. DisconfirmAI's promise of testing investment views against counter-evidence and keeping understanding current sounds interesting, especially the 'Reading' and 'Research' features. However, it's unclear how it aggregates and synthesizes information from disparate sources beyond what I can already find. The 'Radar' feature for scheduled scans is appealing, but I'd need to see if it offers more value than setting up alerts myself. What truly keeps me on my current path is the cost of subscription services, and while this seems more focused, I need more clarity on the depth of analysis and the time commitment. I'm willing to pay $30 per month, but only if it demonstrably saves me time and provides deeper, verifiable insights I can't generate myself.
Simulated interest: 60/100
Shrishti Varrier-NehruneutralToday, I primarily rely on a combination of mobile web searches, PDFs, and spreadsheets to track client exposure to AI-related equities and ETFs. I also manually trace patent filings and supply chain dependencies when necessary, which can be incredibly time-consuming. DisconfirmAI's ability to gather and organize AI investment research, test views against evidence, and potentially automate some of the deeper dives into filings and data seems like a significant step forward. The 'Radar' feature, which scans on a schedule, could save me considerable time. However, I would need to see how effectively it synthesizes complex information and its reliability in identifying counter-evidence before fully committing. The core of my work involves meticulous, verified research, and I'm hesitant to replace that with anything that might oversimplify or miss crucial nuances. The pricing isn't clear on the page, so I can't estimate a monthly cost. I'd need to understand the subscription tiers and what features are included at different levels. I'm looking for tools that streamline information synthesis, not replace critical thinking.
Simulated interest: 50/100
Keep exploring.
Find your next question or see which topics divide AI panels.
What would you ask next?
Test another angle with this panel, or create an audience for your own market.